The 2016 election of Donald Trump brought a seismic shift to the U.S. political landscape, influencing global perceptions of American leadership, national security policy, and defense priorities. As we examine the legacy of Trump’s presidency, we must consider both the geopolitical realignments it sparked and the strategic consequences that continue to shape U.S. defense posture today.
A Shift from Traditional Alliances to Transactional Diplomacy
Trump’s “America First” stance redefined U.S. relationships with longstanding allies, from NATO to the Asia-Pacific. While administrations before him supported multinational organizations and defense alliances, Trump’s approach often questioned these commitments, pushing allies to increase their defense spending and revisit mutual obligations.
NATO, in particular, saw increased pressure to meet its collective 2% GDP spending target. While this led to enhanced military spending from allies, it also strained relationships, challenging the concept of collective security. This shift posed questions about the resilience of these alliances in an era where threats—from cyber incursions to economic warfare—require cooperative defense strategies.
Reshaping U.S. Defense Priorities
Trump’s administration emphasized modernization within the military and reinforced the need for a robust nuclear deterrent. Investments in missile defense systems, next-generation aircrafts, and space-based assets reflected the administration’s commitment to “peace through strength.” Programs such as the Space Force underscored a recognition of new domains of warfare and the importance of technological superiority in conventional and asymmetric conflicts.
Technological Advancements and Cybersecurity
Under Trump, the U.S. took a hardline approach to China, reflecting concerns over intellectual property theft, cybersecurity threats, and the rising influence of Chinese technology globally. Initiatives like banning Huawei from U.S. networks symbolized an era where technological security became intertwined with national defense. In this regard, the administration was keenly aware of the risks associated with emerging technologies, particularly AI, cyber capabilities, and 5G.
These actions set the stage for a continued emphasis on tech sovereignty and defense modernization. However, while new policies aimed to address immediate risks, they also created economic friction, with China-U.S. trade tensions affecting global markets and technological supply chains.
A New Era of Great Power Competition
Trump’s national security policy revived the focus on the “Great Power Competition,” placing China and Russia at the center of U.S. defence strategy. The National Defense Strategy of 2018 emphasized countering these peer competitors, highlighting areas such as cyber warfare, AI, and space technology where the U.S. needed to stay ahead. The increased funding and prioritization of space assets, cyber defenses, and advanced AI research reflect the administration’s view that future conflicts may unfold in virtual and physical realms, requiring innovative and adaptable responses.
The Long-Term Impact: Legacy and Challenges Ahead
The Trump administration’s defense policy highlighted critical shifts that may endure across future administrations:
The emphasis on greater independence from allies signaled to NATO and other organizations the necessity of self-sufficiency. Future administrations will need to balance multilateralism with a pragmatic view of alliance costs and benefits.
By prioritizing cybersecurity, AI, and the defense industrial base, Trump’s policies reinforced the importance of technological edge in national security. As emerging technologies evolve, future leaders will face the dual challenge of innovation and cybersecurity within a contested digital space.
The experience of China-U.S. tensions underscored the risks inherent in economic interdependence. Trump’s approach paved the way for conversations around tech sovereignty and economic security, which will remain central as economies become more digitally integrated in a global ecosystem.
A Lasting Footprint on U.S. National Security
Trump’s victory in the November 2024 election marks a significant turning point in how the U.S. will navigate its defense posture amid evolving technological and geopolitical challenges. His new national security team will need to reassess alliances, prioritize technological investments, and address emerging threats. As America confronts the immediate future and the ongoing regional conflicts in Europe and the Middle East, these shifts will continue to shape its approach to defense and its standing in the world. Additionally, how Trump defines the geopolitical situation will test the nation’s preparedness and resolve to engage with the multifaceted challenges of the 21st century directly.
Forging Our Future Together: The New Era of U.S.-Japan Relations.
GX, DX, and AI innovation at Deloitte Tohmatsu Innovation Park
USJC (U.S. - Japan Council) annual conference in Tokyo
